Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts

Friday, 1 April 2016

Sandwich review: The BLT from Pick Of The Pantry


The official description of this sandwich is:
Slices of Grilled Dry Cured Bacon, Tomatoes, Lettuce & Mayonnaise on Malted Wheatgrain Bread
I had never heard of this sandwich brand before, but even in the packaging this looked promising – two well filled sandwiches, and a good colour to the bacon which seemed to suggest quality ingredients.

I was not disappointed.  BLT is a classic sandwich recipe – almost every sandwich brand makes one.  I have tried many different BLTs over the years, but this is up there with the very best of them.  The bacon is crispy, but not tough, and nicely flavoursome; there is a good balance of ingredients, and no overmayonation; the salad is fresh and the bread is not soggy.

Overall, this was a very enjoyable sandwich experience, and I would buy this sandwich again.

Monday, 25 January 2016

Sandwich review: New York deli style pastrami from M&S Count On Us… range


The official description for this sandwich is –
"Pastrami, Emmental and mustard dressing, spinach, gherkins, sauerkraut on rye bread"
"No mayo" boasts the packet of this low fat sandwich from Marks & Spencer.  That's no bad thing – I don't regard mayonnaise as the evil the calorie-counters do, but regular readers will know I deplore the overmayonation which blights so many of the sandwiches we buy.

Unfortunately, when M&S took out the mayonnaise, they also took out the flavour.  This recipe promised so much – I had expected the mustard dressing, the gherkins and the sauerkraut all to be strong-tasting and make their presence known, but sadly it wasn't to be.

I am hesitant to say that this disappointing blandness is simply a feature of "low fat" recipes which is simply to be expected, as I don't think generalisations are helpful in reviewing sandwiches, but if this example is representative of the genre then the outlook is not good.  I shall try not to let this prejudice me, and put me off trying other calorie-conscious sandwiches, but I shan't be buying this particular sandwich again.

Sandwich review: Aberdeen Angus Beef, Red Onion Chutney & Mustard by M&S


The official description for this sandwich is –
"Aberdeen Angus beef, red onion chutney & mustard on soft white farmhouse bread"
An interesting and bold recipe choice from this premier Marks & Spencer sandwich.  What I will firstly say is that quality of the ingredients is very high, which instantly makes for an enjoyable sandwich experience, and really makes you feel like you are eating quality.

I was unsure, if I am honest, about how the combination of red onion chutney – which is traditionally quite sweet – and mustard would play out as a backdrop for Aberdeen Angus beef.  I would have expected a sweet onion chutney to be paired with something like a strong, tangy cheese, perhaps.  Mustard was an unusual choice.

It worked better than I expected it would, as an overall recipe.  But I don't feel it really grabbed me.  It was fine – but it didn't sparkle.  I think the jury's still out on this recipe, so I would buy this sandwich again to give it another chance, but unless I become a late convert to the idea I think maybe red onion chutney and mustard in one sandwich is possibly an innovative combination too far for Marks & Spencer.

Tuesday, 11 August 2015

Sandwich review: deli2go Turkey, Ham & Swiss with honey & mustard mayonnaise


The official description for this sandwich is:
Roast turkey, honey & mustard mayonnaise, smoked formed ham, Emmental and mixed salad leaves on malted bread with millet and sunflower seeds
If I were to sum up this sandwich in one word, it would be: 'bland'.  There is no main flavour element in the ingredients; roast turkey is a particularly flavourless meat – and Emmental, although not a bad cheese, is hardly a strong flavour either, being a mild and creamy sort of cheese.

What intrigued me here was the honey and mustard mayonnaise – unfortunately, these flavours just don't come through!  I was hoping for a sweet and tangy dressing to complement the smokiness of the ham and the creaminess of the cheese, but sadly none of this materialised.  There was no smokiness to the ham, and the mayonnaise with creamy but not strong in flavour, adding to overall dairy washout with very little flavour.

The nicest part of the sandwich was the bread, which was fresh and nicely grainy – sadly, however, what was inside didn't not stack up, and left very little impression on me at all.

I would not buy this sandwich again.

Monday, 10 August 2015

Sandwich review: Tesco Finest* Beef Topside & Long Clawson Stilton


The official description for this sandwich is:
White bread with oats and barley, medium rare topside beef, free range egg mayonnaise, caramelised onion chutney, Stilton® cheese and rocket.
This is not the first time Tesco's Finest* range has impressed me, but even by their high standards this sandwich was exceptionally good.

All the ingredients were high quality – and fresh (the bread wasn't soggy, the salad wasn't wilted) – and the recipe is an absolute triumph, with every element complementing every other.  The beef works perfectly with the creamy, tangy stilton, balanced out by the sweetness of the onion chutney and the peppery tones of the rocket.  It is really very difficult to find any fault with this sandwich at all.

I would buy this sandwich again.

Wednesday, 29 April 2015

Sandwich review: M&S Roast Beef & Horseradish Mayo


The official description for this sandwich is:
Rare roast British beef with horseradish mayonnaise and lettuce on white bread
This sandwich has suffered from a classic case of overmayonation; the quality of the beef (as good as you would expect from M&S) is sadly masked by an overpowering layer of creamy mayonnaise, making it difficult to enjoy the other ingredients.  It doesn't help that this is supposed to be 'horseradish mayonnaise', but there is only the merest hint of horseradish – it is so mild, it may as well not really be there at all.

Unfortunately, this results in a sandwich which is bland and unsatisfying.  Personally, I would prefer just horseradish sauce, not a specially flavoured mayonnaise, and I would like it to have a bit more bit to it.

I would not buy this sandwich again.

Friday, 24 April 2015

Sandwich review: URBANeat Feta & Roasted Vegetables on Red Pepper Bread


The official description for this sandwich is:
Roasted vegetables with sunblushed red pepper mayonnaise, Greek Feta cheese, Kalamata olives, and spinach on red pepper bread.
This is URBANeat's 'Monthly Special' offering, and is something a little off-the-beaten-track when it comes to sandwiches.  Overall, however, I enjoyed this sandwich – it is an interesting recipe, and it's been generally well-executed.

There are a variety of flavours at work, here, but they all compliment each other nicely, and the filling works well as a whole package.  The only disappointing elements were the promised Kalamata olives – I didn't spot any – and the red pepper bread, which had very little flavour to it and was almost indistinguishable from ordinary bread – as is so often the case with 'speciality' breads in these kinds of situations.

Nevertheless, I did enjoy this sandwich, and I am very pleased to see established brands like URBANeat branching out, pushing the boundaries and trying new things.

I would buy this sandwich again.

Thursday, 9 April 2015

Sandwich review: Tesco finest* Wiltshire Cured Ham Hock and Extra Mature Cheddar



The official description for this sandwich is:
White bread with oat and barley, Ham Hock, West Country extra mature cheddar cheese, onion and ale chutney, free range egg mayonnaise and mixed leaf.
Tesco have really pulled off something special here.  The balance of flavours and the quality of the ingredients is very impressive.  The strength of the cheese in sandwiches has been a particular bugbear of mine recently, as I always feel companies err on the side of caution and make their cheeses too mild – thankfully, Tesco are using extra mature cheddar here, and the flavour does actually come through in the sandwich.  The mix of the cheddar and the 'tangy onion and ale chutney' is perfect.

Overall, this is fantastic sandwich – the concept is a simple, elegant recipe, but it has been extremely well executed, and I can't commend Tesco enough on this effort.

I would buy this sandwich again.

Thursday, 5 February 2015

Thomas Clipper Mark One razor


I'm finally getting around to writing this, having been one of the first people (I was Order #2) to order a razor from brand new London-based company Thomas Clipper last year.

Thomas Clipper make classic double-edged single blade razors with solid stainless steel handles for balance.  The brand was brought to my attention in late 2014, and I was keen to try their products, so when they began trading I ordered a Mark One razor with frankincense shaving oil and organic cotton flannel.

So, the first thing that may strike you about this is that it seems quite expensive.  £65 for a razor?  That's a lot of money!  (Although it is possible to buy just the Mark One razor, without the oil and flannel, for only £49.)  However, when I received my order and looked inside the presentation box I could see straight away why it costs as much as it does.


This thing is about as far removed from a cheap, flimsy, plastic disposable razor as it's possible to get.  The build quality is fantastic, and you can tell the attention to detail which has gone into the design and manufacturer of the product the second you pick it up; unlike the scratchy weightlessness of a cheap plastic razor, the Thomas Clipper Mark One has a solid weight to it which belies quality craftsmanship, and yet feel perfectly balanced in your hand.  You may feel you're paying a lot for the razor, but it's a high-end product which will definitely last you years and years.  (Obviously you'll need to replace the blade fairly often – although the Mark One does come with a box of ten blades to start you off – but that is a much smaller concern.)


Also included in the price is a bottle of frankincense shaving oil, and an organic cotton flannel.  A good shave is as much about the preparation as it is about actually shaving, and these extras come beautifully presented along with the Mark One razor itself.


In action, the Mark One feels easy to use; the razor glides rather than drags across the skin (again, this is partly down to preparation – I'm using the Thomas Clipper's shaving oil along with Proraso shaving cream and a Wilkinson's Sword shaving brush which probably needs replacing) and the perfect balance between the razor's head and its handle makes shaving feel effortless.

Overall, I would say that the Mark One is definitely worth what you pay for it.  Thomas Clipper have done an excellent job in making a razor which is well-built and feels nice to use, which is good for your skin (traditional single blade razors are better for you than more modern designs), and which makes you feel like you own something special, hand-crafted, worth having and which will serve you well for many years to come.

Wednesday, 31 December 2014

A look back at 2014

Today is the last day of 2014, while tomorrow will be a 2015.  Nothing will change, of course, as we cross that imaginary line in the sand, as the calendar is simply an arbitrary construct, as are all ways of organising time.  Nevertheless, it customary at this time of year to look back over the past twelve months and reflect on the good times, and what one has achieved, with an air of smug self-satisfaction, and I would hate to be the only person on the internet not joining in with this self-congratulatory tradition.

  • I left the radiators on all year 'round, because I wanted to see what it would be like to live in the Seychelles (where they worship radiators as demigods).
  • I briefly spoke on the phone with the Pope but we got cut off when he lost signal.
  • I won three rounds of 'Uno' in a row.
  • I invented a new way of peeling vegetables which extracts the inner part of the vegetable through a tube rather than scraping off the outer layers in the old and inefficient method.
  • My friends all chipped in to buy me shares in the World's Largest Cucumber.
  • I rowed from Britain to Ireland across the Irish Sea in a boat made entirely from elastic bands.
  • I ate over 19,000 chips.
Another successful year!  Thanks for being a part of it – and here's to 2015.

Tuesday, 16 December 2014

Sandwich review: Roast chicken salad with black pepper mayonnaise and juicy tomatoes by deli2go



The official description for this sandwich is:
Roast chicken breast, curly lettuce, free range black pepper mayonnaise and tomato on malted wheatgrain bread
Although this sandwich was perfectly serviceable, I felt a little let down by its lack of flavour.  The 'black pepper mayonnaise' was intriguing, and a large part of what drew me to this sandwich in the first place – in the end, though, the black pepper never really made itself known, and I would've been hard pressed to tell the difference between this and ordinary mayonnaise.

Unfortunately, this rather set the tone for the rest of the sandwich experience – whilst perfectly edible, this sandwich and all its ingredients fell a good way short of 'spectacular', landing instead in 'disappointingly tame'.  I would not buy this sandwich again.

Sandwich review: Two cheese and red onion chutney on malted wheatgrain bread by URBANeat



The official description for this sandwich is:
Cheddar and Red Leicester cheese with mayonnaise, caramelised red onion confit, spinach, red onion and chives on malted wheatgrain bread
This sandwich came highly recommended by my friends and colleagues in The Ultra '90s, so I was intrigued to sample it, and put some thoughts down on this Blog.  Thankfully, it did not disappoint!

I confess I had been slightly nervous about trying this sandwich, and about the possibility of having to tell those who spoke so highly of it that I hadn't actually been that impressed.  Luckily, this was never an issue, as this is a very enjoyable sandwich indeed; cheese and onion is a classic flavour combination which it is difficult to get wrong, but in this instance URBANeat get it very right – the biggest triumph here is the red onion chutney, which is brilliantly executed with the perfect balance between sweet and tangy flavours.

My only criticism of this sandwich would be that I might have preferred a slightly more mature cheddar cheese.  I often feel that the cheeses chosen by sandwich manufacturers are a little blander than I might like – I guess sandwich companies want to appeal to as wide a range of customers as possible, and URBANeat are no exception here as they err on the side of caution with a mild, creamy cheddar.  My tastes are for stronger, more full-bodied cheeses, and I would love to try a version of this sandwich with a more mature cheddar – nevertheless, this is a minor point in the grand scheme of things, and this is still a very well executed, enjoyable sandwich, which I would have no qualms about buying again.

Wednesday, 13 August 2014

Sandwich review: Chicken, cheese & bacon club with mustard mayo & salad on white bread by Sainsbury's



The official description for this sandwich is:
"Succulent British chicken breast, maple cured bacon with tangy, mature Cheddar, and served with cucumber, juicy vine-ripened tomatoes & crisp lettuce"
A pleasing recipe, overall, with lots of elements guaranteed to fit right in together.  In particular, the balance between the chicken and the bacon was good, and neither overpowered the other - while the mustard mayonnaise actually did have a mustard flavour to it, and was used sparingly enough not to create the alarming overmayonation we so often see in these situations, and the salad was reasonably crisp and fresh.

However, the age-old problem which afflicts all 'club'-style sandwiches was not absent in this case either… The extra slice of bread in the middle of the sandwich made the balance of textures too doughy overall - and, being surround by filling on both sides instead of just on one side, this central slice of bread (as so often happens) became soggy and unappetising.  Unfortunately, this means that an otherwise excellent sandwich was ruined by an over prevalence of damp bread, and that I would not in fact buy this sandwich again.

I am still waiting to experience the a sandwich where the three-slice 'club sandwich' concept is executed effectively - but I am beginning to despair of this ever actually happening.

Sandwich review: Double Gloucester Cheese & Ale Chutney by Delicious (at Boots)



The official description for this sandwich is:
"Double Gloucester cheese with ale chutney and mixed salad leaves on malted bread"
A rare occasion of a vegetarian sandwich being sized up today.  The use of Double Gloucester cheese intrigued me, as most sandwich recipes stick fairly rigidly to using only bland Cheddar, no matter how inventive or off-the-wall the rest of the filling ingredients may be!

In this case, the Double Gloucester cheese was a delight, and had a strong enough flavour to carry the entire sandwich on its own merit as the main ingredient in the filling.  My only criticism is that it was presented as grated cheese, rather than in slices - this would not normally be an issue, but when it comes to eating a sandwich in the car grated cheese is much harder to control as it has so many more individual elements, and you can end up with tiny cheese shavings getting everywhere.  This small gripe aside, however, the cheese was very enjoyable.

The ale chutney was also pleasantly flavoursome.  I am fairly used to these things being mere shadows of what they promise to be, but in this instance the chutney did live up to its billing rather well - it had all all the sweet, tangy fruitiness essential to a chutney, but you could definitely taste the flavour of a good British ale in there as well.  It was a well-balanced accompaniment to the cheese, and made for a well-rounded sandwich recipe overall.

The mixed salad leaves were a little wilted and flavourless, but even this was not sufficient to put me off saying that I was left impressed by this sandwich, and I would definitely buy it again.

Sandwich review: BBQ Pulled Pork by Ginsters



The official description for this sandwich is:
"British pulled pork with BBQ sauce, ranch dressing and fresh spinach leaves on white bread"
'Pulled pork' is the current culinary obsession, so it was only a matter of time before it turned up in sandwiches too.  I gave this limited edition offering from Ginsters a try, and found it to be overall quite pleasant.

The pork meat was tender and flavoursome (something which not all sandwich meat manages), and the BBQ sauce had a nice balance of sweet, yet tangy.  I also enjoyed the inclusion of the spinach leaves, which lived up to description of 'fresh' and added a crunchy salad texture to the sandwich (again, sandwich salad leaves have often reached a 'limp and wilted' state by the time they are consumed - not so, in this case).

The only element of this sandwich which disappointed was the ranch dressing - which I could barely taste at all.  I saw no sign of this as ate the sandwich - this may, however, have been something of a blessing in disguise, as it seemed a somewhat incongruous addition to an otherwise fairly cohesive sandwich recipe, and I am not sure what exactly it would have added, had it been present.

Overall, I enjoyed this sandwich, and I would buy it again.

Thursday, 12 June 2014

Sandwich review: Salt Beef, Cheddar & Piccalilli from deli2go



The official description of this sandwich is -
Salt beef, mild Cheddar cheese, piccalilli, lettuce and free range mayonnaise on onion bread
This sandwich was an interesting balance of flavours.  I think, in many ways, deli2go have tried to be too clever here, and some of the tastes simply don't come through - the 'onion bread', for example, added very little which couldn't have been achieved with ordinary wholemeal bread.  However, for those flavours which did announce themselves, nothing was overpowering, and the overall effect was very pleasant.

Despite containing mayonnaise, this was kept to a sensible quantity, and the sandwich was mercifully not overmayonnated.  The salt beef had a nice flavour to it, and the piccalilli was sweet and tangy, and balanced well with the salt beef.  As ever, I would've preferred a stronger cheese, instead of the rather too popular mild Cheddar, but one cannot have everything.

On the whole, I enjoyed this sandwich, and thought the concept, if a little cluttered, still managed to work well as a recipe.

I would buy this sandwich again.

Wednesday, 7 May 2014

Sandwich review: Chicken, Ham & Cheddar from deli2go, and Smoked Ham & Coleslaw by Marks & Spencer's Simply M&S range



The official description for each of these sandwiches is:
Roast chicken breast, smoked formed ham, mild cheddar cheese, tomato, mixed salad leaves, and English mustard mayonnaise on malted wheatgrain bread (left)
and:
Smoked British ham with shredded cabbage, carrots, onions and mustard in mayonnaise on malted brown bread (right)
Now, I have decided to review these two sandwiches together, instead of individually, for a number of reasons.  Firstly, both fillings include ham - nothing hugely weird about this, of course, but in bought sandwiches bacon is far more normal.  And, secondly, I ate these two sandwiches within a couple of days of each, and was struck by the similarities between the two of them - even if they purport to be vastly different sandwiches.

If I were asked to describe both sandwiches in one word, I would say:  'overmayonated'.  (I know that isn't a real word, but I am hoping it will catch on.)  Both M&S and deli2go have made the mistake of simply lathering their creations in mayonnaise in the hope that this will make them enjoyable.  It doesn't.

The creamy swathes of mayonnaise ensured that the other flavours (which could have been so good) were left sadly muted and subdued.  In much the same way that putting too much milk into a cup of tea or coffee will ruin in, here the flavours of smoked ham, onions and English mustard which should've come bounding strongly through were barely present.

It was a shame that deli2go also chose to use 'mild cheddar cheese'.  A strong cheddar would've saved the sandwich from interminable blandness - as it was, however, the mild cheese simply added to the overall palette of tasteless dairy creaminess, and added nothing to the sandwich save its texture.

On the whole, I was left disappointed by these two sandwiches - either of which could quite easily have been salvaged with stronger flavours and slightly less mayonnaise.

I would not buy either of these sandwiches again.

Monday, 24 March 2014

Regurgitated media

I was recently introduced to the phenomenon of GoggleBox - a television programme on Channel 4.  Billed as a window into the world of 'Britain's most opinionated viewers', GoggleBox features a variety of 'ordinary people' watching television and talking about it.

It was not long into my first viewing of GoggleBox before I realised that instead of watching television, I was watching other people watch television.  I was consuming second-hand television - instead of choosing to watch something myself, and form my own opinions about it, I had chosen to watch other people do that.

Quite apart from the fact that we are more obsessed that we have ever been about what 'ordinary people' think about anything (that is a topic for another day!), this must be a very easy programme for Channel 4 to make.  It doesn't need a set, or costumes, or scripts, or stuntmen - it doesn't even need any original or creative thinking to make it.  And this, I think, is the main issue I have with GoggleBox; there's nothing new in it - it is regurgitated media.

More and more media these days falls into this category.  On the internet, you'd probably expect that - the average Tumblr Blog probably has more content 'reblogged' from other users than original posts written by the Blog's owner (just one of the reasons why I don't like Tumblr).  But sites like BuzzFeed have taken collating and redistributing other people's material to a whole new level - and now even serious, reputable newspapers post 'articles' which are just a collection of Tweets or posts from other sources, apparently thinking that this constitutes journalism.

On television, though, that feels a little like cheating.  GoggleBox is on at nine o'clock on a Friday night - that's seriously mainstream primetime television - but it doesn't require the creation of any original material at all.  It is simply relaying people's reactions to other original programmes which have already been broadcast.  Channel 4 are passing this off as a television programme in its own right, but I think they're having a laugh.

Monday, 6 January 2014

More #Sherlock thoughts

I'm afraid to say the second episode of the newest series of the BBC's Sherlock impressed me as little as the first episode did.

Once again, crowds of fawning fans gathered on Twitter, Tumblr and (presumably) Trams to spew several gigabytes of praise and cutesy adulation - and so, once again, I feel duty bound to set out an alternative point-of-view on a Blog which (almost) nobody reads.

My biggest gripe with the second episode of Sherlock is the treatment of Sherlock's personality - specifically, the increasing 'humanisation' of him as a character.  Benedict Cumberbatch has always done a fantastic job of portraying Sherlock Holmes as he is meant to be - not just emotionless but disdainful of emotion, and of anything which is removed from pure logic and reason.  (For example, he never much took to Ableton.*)  However, as I mentioned before, I feel Sherlock's writers are moving further and further away from the original character - I've nothing against different adaptations, of course, but if you start to change the fundamentals of the character, it's no longer Sherlock Holmes at all.

Conan Doyle's Holmes never gets drunk.  (Despite being actually a far greater drug user and smoker than the modern Sherlock, he always knows his limits and would never allow himself to get out-of-control.  Holmes vomiting on a client's carpet? Unthinkable!)  He is never one for public displays of affection.  And he would never make a sexually suggestive comment about handcuffs to a bridesmaid!

But, most importantly, although he maybe aware of his own flaws, he does not see them as flaws.

Holmes may not be keen on emotions, but that does not mean he does not understand them.  He is a very intelligent, highly perceptive man who probably understands more of human interaction than most of the people who actually value it.  This is made particularly clear in The Adventure of Charles August Milverton, in which Holmes becomes engaged - he does so only to gain vital information for his case, of course (he has no feelings for the woman - Agatha - involved) but this just goes to show that he's more than capable of sweet-talking, romancing and gaining the trust of another person, should he so wish.

Holmes knows how to act like a "normal" (for want of a better word person) - and does so when it suits him - but he prefers not to.

In the BBC's Sherlock, though, the eponymous character seems equally aware of his eccentricities - but uncharacteristically embarrassed by them.  He mentions several times that he is aware of how difficult he must be to live and to work with; nothing wrong with that, but this is done in an empathetic way which at times verges on apologetic.  This, to me, is unforgivable - Sherlock Holmes would never apologise for being Sherlock Holmes!

Conan Doyle's Holmes may know that most other people view him as a strange, cold, emotionless being - but he is not ashamed or worried by this.  Quite the opposite, in fact - he believes that this is how everyone should be.

Sherlock, no matter how well-acted, spectacularly misses this point.


* Sorry - that's a music technology joke.

Thursday, 2 January 2014

#Sherlock: a review

Like many people, I watched the return of BBC1's Sherlock last night.  Unlike many people, I was not overly impressed.  Having taken twenty-four hours to organise my thoughts on the matter, I am going to write about why.

There were some good things about Sherlock, which I really enjoyed - in particular, I liked the passing reference to The Adventure Of The Blue Carbuncle (the deductions Holmes makes from a lost hat), which I thought was very cleverly done.

Unfortunately, though, this latest instalment of the BBC's modernisation amplifies many of the flaws which I thought were apparent in the first two series, and as such suffers from a huge amount of over complication and needlessly elaborate plot devices.  This was evident in a few key points, in particular...

Firstly, the fact that Sherlock had planned to survive falling from the top of the building - directly at odds with Conan Doyle's Holmes, who walks to the Reichenbach Fall convinced he is genuinely going to die.

This problem stems from the over-reliance on Moriarty which I highlighted in my post about the previous series - by making Sherlock premeditate faking his own death (and in a typically over-elaborate way), it was necessary to give him a reason for this grand deception, and thus the Moriarty storyline spiralled out-of-control - but ultimately goes a long way beyond this.  In carrying out this scheme (and it is worth noting that the writers still haven't provided a definitive answer as to how this was done), so many extra helpers would have been required that the secret would surely not have stayed hidden for long.  Conan Doyle's Holmes prefers always to operate alone - the very idea of involving so many other people in a plan of such great importance and precision is so unlike him that it jars with the rest of Sherlock's characterisation.

Indeed, at one point in the episode it feels rather as though the entire ruse has been wholly for John Watson's benefit - and that he is the only one who wasn't in on it from the start, like one great big magic trick.  While this may provide some colourful and dynamic scenes when Sherlock first reveals himself to John two years on, the idea is patently absurd.

The second big issue I had with the episode is again something which has grated on me before in the previous series, but which has this time been taken to a whole new level.  I am talking here about the writers' seemingly insatiable need to make everything within the plot link up, and for all the storylines to intertwine.

This is typically done by having one persistent "enemy", and making each crime which Sherlock solves ultimately trace back to this source (usually in an implausibly convoluted way).  In the past, this was done (wrongly) with the character of Moriarty - in this new series, that vacancy seems to have been filled by "a terrorist organisation" about which we currently know very little, but which appears already to have been cast in the rĂ´le of Sherlock's "nemesis".

This warping of the Sherlock Holmes paradigm is one with which I feel very uneasy.  In Conan Doyle's stories, the vast majority of Holmes' cases are standalone crimes, each with their own perpetrators and their own victims - not assignments handed down to him by agents of the British state, in which the puzzle must be solved against the clock and with enormously high stakes.  Most of the cases solved by Conan Doyle's Holmes are, in the grand scheme of things, actually rather petty - there are not hundreds of lives at stake, there is not a risk to an entire nation, and the cases come to him by way of private clients seeking his assistance, not government agents.  The only common thread running through all of Holmes' cases is that they are all interesting.

Unfortunately, it seems that the writers of Sherlock have failed to grasp this fact.  They start with the premise that Sherlock Holmes has to save the world (in as spectacular a style as possible) at the end of every episode, and work backwards from there, twisting the story as they go in order to force it into being interesting.  The biggest - and therefore most ridiculous - way in which this is achieved is by making the episodes' criminals (sorry, criminal masterminds) leave smug, self-satisfied clues for Sherlock as he attempts to solve the mystery.

Again, this began in the previous series, with Moriarty setting Sherlock little tests with clues and pointers provided and a clock ticking in the background for no reason other than for his own amusement, but was also ratcheted up a notch in the latest episode when John Watson was kidnapped and almost burnt alive on a Guy Fawkes' Night bonfire.

Not only did this segment have very little to do with the overall plot of the episode (other than providing a convenient reason for John to forgive Sherlock after having been angry with him following his initial reappearance), but it was another example of the programme's criminals seeming to care more about agitating Sherlock than their actual crimes.  This, added to the fact that this entire sequence of events was left completely unexplained - and that we still have no idea who kidnapped John in that way, or why they did that - made this part of the episode intensely frustrating.

The need to make every crime both an intensely personal affair and on a gargantuan scale affecting thousands of ordinary people results in plotlines which are both intolerably byzantine and extraordinarily flimsy.

Finally, the business with Sherlock's parents showing up at his flat was so unnecessary that I struggle to understand why it was included at all.  Granted, it didn't really hurt to include them (other than that it might be straying dangerously close to making people see Sherlock's character as more "human", I suppose) but it added nothing to the episode in any way, and was therefore a total waste of time.

So, there you have it.  As ever, the acting was superb - Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman work as brilliantly together as always - and there was plenty of action and suspense to keep viewers hooked.  However, I worry that the writers are overcomplicating things just for the sake of it - I think they should revisit the omnibus edition of Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories, before they forget what Sherlock Holmes is supposed to be all about.